Field of Science

Fear and God


Daniel Treisman, a political scientist at UCLA, has come up with a way to measure how fearful nations are. Many surveys ask respondents how worried they are about a range of subjects - war, terrorism, crime, environmental pollution, etc. What Treisman found is that is that if an individual admit to being worried about one threat, they are also highly likely to say they are worried about the others.

In other words, any given individual tends to be generally fearful, or generally unafraid. That means you can construct an 'Index of Fear' by averaging the responses to several questions.

Now, the interesting thing is that fear is often not all that closely linked to real danger. There was no relationship between fear of BSE and actual number of cases, and only a weak relationship between fear of medical errors and the number of medical errors, and between terrorism and number of terrorist attacks. Fear of bird flu was actually highest in the countries with the fewest cases!

Fear was influenced by all sorts of  weird effects. People are less scared if you quiz them in the evenings - Treisman speculates they may have partaken of a few bevvies already!


Treisman also found that Catholic countries were more fearful than Protestant - Greece, the only Orthodox country analysed, was more fearful still.

But more important that religious affiliation (or, indeed, virtually anything else) was belief in Heaven and Hell. Belief in Heaven tended to lower fear somewhat, but belief in Hell had a dramatic and opposite effect.

Those countries where a lot of people believed in Hell were more fearful across the range of potential threats. In fact, much of the apparent relationship between religious traditions and fear could be explained by the degree of hell-belief.

That chimes with some other research showing that British Christians are made less anxious by thoughts of death than are British Muslims, mainly because the Christians are less likely to believe in Hell.

Of course, it may be that people living in genuinely scary countries are more likely to believe in Hell. But Treisman adjusted for factors that are linked to real danger - like poverty, authoritarian rule, war, and even more touchy-feely factors like educational styles, cultural masculinity and individualism. And remember he also found that fear is a social construct, and only loosely related to objective threats.

To me, this looks like good evidence that putting the fear of god into people actually makes them more fearful of everything else - and that, of course, has a number of interesting political and social ramifications!


Creative Commons License This article by Tom Rees was first published on Epiphenom. It is licensed under Creative Commons.

5 comments:

  1. Interesting article. I thought it well worth mentioning that the concept of the "fear of God" which is biblical, really means something more related to respect & honour. It's not the negative, trembling in our boots kind of fear. To conclude, biblical fear of God is one thing and ignorant public fear of God is another.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am told that fearful people seek religion. You are saying that religion creates fearful people. Any ideologue, religious or not, can do that. Rally round the flag. Weapons of mass destruction. Illegal alien. I suspect that The Tea Party is not operating out of fear because of a belief in hell.

    I agree that there is some correlation. But I suspect an agenda. The interjection of some brain science is a distraction. I may have missed it but I didn't see a use of that information in the paper. Belief in Hell needs to be unpacked. Do they want hell for those who are causing them to be fearful or do they fear hell for themselves. People who feel persecuted think apocalyptically.

    Just thinking.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This fear index correlates well with GINI index (it misures income inequality, the greater the index the greater the inequality):

    Spain 34.7
    Greece 34.3
    Ireland 34.3
    Italy 36
    UK 36
    France 32.7
    Netherlands 30.9
    Finland 26.9
    Sweden 25
    Denmark 24.7

    It seems that more inequality is linked to a more fearfull society.

    And, even without checking, I would say that more inequality correlates to more belive in God; but I'd also say that the correlation between inequality and church attendance is there, but is not as stronger as to belive in God.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dutch, yes there are lots of ways that demagogues can stir up fear. What this study suggests is that one tool is to focus on the 'punishment' aspects of religion. People can promote hell in order to stir up more generalised fear.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anon: Income inequality seems to be a good, generalised measure of societal health. An you're right that it does connect with religion. In fact I showed a correlation with prayer frequency, even after taking into account other factors linked to religion, in a paper published back in 2009 (you can see the blog post about it here). Another study showed a similar effect with Church attendance.

    ReplyDelete

Markup Key:
- <b>bold</b> = bold
- <i>italic</i> = italic
- <a href="http://www.fieldofscience.com/">FoS</a> = FoS