Field of Science

Does education mean more or less religion? It depends on the country

The relationship between education, intelligence, and religion is endlessly fascinating. Previous studies have shown that nations with higher average IQ tend to be less religious, and this holds for individuals too - in a limited way. The question is, why might this be?

Gerhard Meisenberg, at Ross University Medical School in Dominica, and colleagues have conducted a new analysis of world-wide data using a novel approach.

Using data from the World Values Survey they showed that in all regions of the world except Sub-Saharan Africa, educated people tend to have lower religious beliefs. However, educated people were only less likely to go to religious services in ex-communist nations and in the Middle East, and they are actually more likely to go to religious services in English-speaking countries and in South/South-East Asia (as well as sub-Saharan Africa).

That's pretty much what you would expect from other data. Educated people are less likely to believe, but are more motivated to fit in with social expectations. The effect is quite small, though.

Then Meisenberg moved on to look at IQ. Now, IQ is only available as a crude estimate of average IQ in each nation, and should probably be regarded as a measure of 'cognitive development'. Countries with a better education system, but also with better health and better access to the sort of 'enrichment' activities common in wealthy nations, are going to do better at the abstract problem solving that typifies IQ tests.

When Meisenberg put these average national IQs into a model, he found that they were better able to predict religious belief than either education or GDP - or a variety of other factors, such as the dominant religion and level of corruption.

Digging further, he found that, the negative relationship between education and religious beliefs is strongest in countries with moderately high average IQ (as shown in the graphic).

Meisenberg concludes that, overall, there is a "negligible relationship between intelligence and religiosity in advanced societies".

However, when comparing between countries at different levels of economic development, "religious belief declines sharply with rising education and, especially, intelligence.

What Meisanberg thinks is that, at moderate levels of economic development, there is a 'clash of cultures' between scientific and religious worldviews. Religion in these countries is tha dogmatic, traditional religion that makes empirical claims about how the world works. Intelligent, educated people reject these claims.

In Sweden, the UK, Hong Kong and South Korea, educated people tend to be more religious. Meisenberg thinks that this is because religion in these countries (and other cognitively advanced countries) has evolved. In these countries religion variants have been developed that abandons claims about the real world. Instead religion is "assigned to a realm in which rational analysis is either off limits, or is applied to axioms that are not supported by observation and are, in this sense, irrational".

In other wordS, in the most developed countries, a new form of religion has developed that appeals to educated people.

David Voas, a demographer at the Institute for Social and Economic Research at the University of Essex, has examined the UK data in detail. He thinks that what has happened is that both the educated and the uneducated have become less religious in recent decades - but the fall off has been faster for the uneducated. The result is that now the educated are more religious  than the uneducated (even though they are less religious than before).

Of course, these two explanations are compatible. Perhaps the reason that the educated have hung on to religion is that they have developed sophisticated, counter-intuitive forms of religion. And the uneducated simply aren't interested in these new-fangled kinds of religion, any more than they are interested in the old sort!


ResearchBlogging.org
Gerhard Meisenberg, Heiner Rindermann, Hardik Patel, & Michael A. Woodley (2012). Is it smart to believe in God? The relationship of religiosity with education and intelligence Temas em Psicologia, 20 (1), 101-120

Creative Commons License This article by Tom Rees was first published on Epiphenom. It is licensed under Creative Commons.

4 comments:

  1. I heard that educated people are also less likely to vaccinate their children.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You heard wrong. Most educated people can read literature and realize that the idiot who came up with the vaccine = autism study was lying. Flat out lying, not mistaken, not incorrect, lying. He was being paid by lawyers to come up with the results they wanted to prop up a law suit. Most educated people understand that vaccines were created to stop the needless deaths and crippling side effects of horrific diseases. Most educated people know that herd immunity is only going to go so far in protecting us as we've seen outbreaks of several preventable diseases over the past decade in areas where people refuse to vaccinate.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I hope you are right. Really I am.
    But the problem seems to be real.

    Let me cite one article.

    "Denial of the benefits of vaccination is strong in educated areas, like Boulder or Marin county, California — being educated doesn’t mean you get things right, and in fact can make people believe in their own knowledge even more strongly. They go online and find antivax literature which magnifies their own beliefs."

    from
    http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2012/04/09/whooping-cough-outbreak-in-boulder/

    Also quick search on internet seems to confirm that.

    So educated people are more religious and can also show other irrational behaviors. I think something going on here.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I find this article very interesting. My life does not involve religion but I can see how some "religious" have evolved their own religion to suit their evolving lifestyles. It appears to be more of a "comfortable" type of culture. If that makes any sense. Living in the south, it is a part of the culture. A way of living that goes along with sweet ice tea.

    ReplyDelete

Markup Key:
- <b>bold</b> = bold
- <i>italic</i> = italic
- <a href="http://www.fieldofscience.com/">FoS</a> = FoS